There are many religions and churches today claiming to be of God. Some religions even make the exclusive claim that they are God’s “one true church” or they are God’s one true present dispenser of God’s truth.
Their common claim is that you as a reader of the Bible do not have the right and authority to judge the truthfulness of their claims by the Bible. They claim that you cannot go by the Bible alone. They claim you must submit to their teaching authority.
For example, in its publications the Watchtower bases its claim upon Matthew 24:45 as I recall. I placed many cross references for that verse in the The New Treasury of Scripture Knowledge.
Matthew 24:45 Who then is a faithful and wise servant, whom his lord hath made ruler over his household, to give them meat in due season?
Matthew 24:45. Who then is. FS121I1, +Ge 3:7. Lk 12:35, 36, 37, 38, 41, 42, 43, 44. *Lk 16:10, 11, 12. *Lk 19:17. +*Ac 20:28. 1Co 4:1, 2. 1Ti 1:12. **2Ti 2:2. He 3:5. 1 P 4:10, 11. Re 2:13. faithful. +*Mt 13:52. +*Mt 25:21. +*Ge 18:19. 30:29. 2Ki 12:15. Ne 7:2. Ps 101:2, *Ps 101:6. +*Je 23:28 note. %**Ezk 13:7. *Ezk 48:11. Ro 12:7. +*1Co 4:2, 17. +*Col 1:7. 1Ti 3:3. +*2Ti 2:2. Titus 2:10. *He 3:5. 1Pe 4:10. 3 J 5. wise. +Mt 25:2. Ex 36:4. Pr 14:35. +*Da 11:33 note. **Da 12:3. 1Co 3:10, 11, 12, 13, 14. Col 1:28. servant. +*Mt 10:24, 25. +*Mt 20:27. +*Mt 23:11. Ru 2:6. Mk 13:34. Lk 12:37. *Ro 12:3. *Php 2:3. Titus 1:7. his lord. Mk 13:34. Lk 12:37. hath made ruler. Gr. kathistēmi [(S#2525g), to place down (permanently), that is, (figuratively) to designate, constitute, convoy (Strong): Rendered (1) make: Lk 12:14. Ac 7:10, 27, 35. Ro 5:19. He 7:28. 2 P 1:8. (2) make ruler: Mt 24:45, 47. 25:21, 23. Lk 12:42, 44. (3) ordain: Titus 1:5. He 5:1. 8:3. (4) be: Ja 3:6. 4:4. (5) appoint: Ac 6:3. (6) conduct: Ac 17:15. (7) set: He 2:7]. *Mt 25:21. +*Ps 149:9. %**2Co 1:24. *1Ti 3:5. *1Ti 5:17. 2Ti 2:12. *He 13:7, 17, 24. **1Pe 5:1, 2, 3. Re 2:27. over. or, at the head of. Gr. epi (S#1909g). household. Jn 14:2 note. +Ro 16:5. Ga 6:10. Ep 2:19. He 3:5, 6. to give. +*Mt 13:52. 16:19. **Mt 25:35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40. Ge 47:23. Pr 31:15. Ezk 34:2. Jn 21:15, 16, 17. +*Ac 20:28. *1Co 3:1, 2. 2Co 4:1, 2. Ga 4:15. +*Ep 4:11, 12, 13. 2Ti 2:2. 1Pe 4:10, 11. 5:1, 2, 3. meat. FS121D4. Meat put by the Figure Metonymy (of Cause) for all kinds of food. Mt 4:4. 6:11. 2 K 25:29. Jb 36:31. +Ps 104:27. 145:15. +Pr 27:27. 31:15. **Je 3:15. Ezk 46:24. +*Da 11:33. 1Co 3:2. *Ja 3:11. due season. +*Mt 21:41, 43. *Ge 17:21 (+S#4150h). Le 23:2 note. Nu 28:2 note. 2 K 25:30. +*1 Ch 12:32. *Ps 1:3. *Ps 104:27. Ec 10:17. %*Je 8:7. *Da 12:4, 7, 9, 10. +*Lk 12:42. *2Ti 4:2. +*He 3:13. +*He 4:16.
The Jehovah’s Witnesses and their organization arrogate to themselves the position of being the “faithful and wise servant.” Their organization is the only organization on earth in this day authorized by Jehovah to dispense “meat in due season,” that is, spiritual truth from the Bible as correctly interpreted only by them. They alone are Jehovah’s designated “ruler over his household,” hence their claim to exclusive divine authority.
When such truth-claims are asserted, we must examine them in the light of what the Bible itself actually teaches. To understand what the Bible teaches at Matthew 24:45 it is necessary to carefully compare this verse with all the other verses in the Bible that shed light on it. I have furnished above as complete a collection of cross references as you are likely to ever find for this verse. If this is a matter of interest to you (and if you are a Jehovah’s Witness, or if you are reading their literature or are being visited by them from time to time you ought to be!), you are invited to search the Scriptures carefully by consulting these references. You will be surprised by just how much light is shed on this text by comparing each phrase or word with the related Scripture passages.
We are not obligated by Scripture to follow some supposed official “teaching authority.” I find no Scripture justification for such a notion. JWs themselves use Romans 14:12 to warn that we all must examine our religion carefully to be sure it agrees with the Bible. They need to subject themselves to the same examination. They are proven absolutely mistaken by considering carefully the cross references given for even one verse, Isaiah 55:3.
Romans 14:12 So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God.
Romans 14:12. every one. ver. 10 (Ro 14:10). give account. *Ec 11:9. +*Mt 12:36. *+Mt 16:27 note. Mt 18:23, etc. +*Mt 25:19. +*Lk 12:48. *Lk 16:2. 19:15. Ac 24:25. *Ga 6:5. He 4:13. 13:17. *1Pe 4:4, 5. of himself. Dt 24:16. *Jb 19:4. Pr 9:12. Je 31:30. Ezk 14:10 note. +*Ezk 18:20 note. Ga 6:5. Re 2:23. 22:12. to God. ver. 10 (Ro 14:10). *Jn 10:30.
Isa 55:3 Incline your ear, and come unto me: hear, and your soul shall live; and I will make an everlasting covenant with you, even the sure mercies of David.
Isaiah 55:3. Incline. Is 51:1. Ps 78:1. 119:112. Pr 4:20. 15:31. 22:17. Zc 7:7. come. *Mt 11:28. **Jn 6:37, 44, 45. 7:37. He 11:6. 1Pe 2:4. hear. Is 44:1. 48:12. 49:1. Dt 28:1. 30:10. 2 Ch 24:19. Ps 81:8. *Ps 95:7. Pr 1:33. 2:2. +**Pr 18:17. Mt 13:16. 15:10. 17:5. +**Mk 4:24. Lk 6:47. +**Lk 8:18. *Lk 9:35. **Jn 5:24, 25. 8:47. **Jn 10:27. Ac 3:22. He 3:7. 5:9. soul. Heb. nephesh, +Ge 12:13. shall live. +*Ge 15:6. 19:20. +*Le 18:5 note. Pr 4:4. 7:2. Je 38:20. Am 5:4. +*Hab 2:4. **Jn 10:27, 28. and I will make. Is 54:8. 61:8. Ge 17:7. 2 S 23:5. Je 31:33, 34. 32:40. *Je 50:5. Ezk 16:60. 34:25. 37:26. Da 9:27 x. *He 13:20. everlasting. Heb. olam, +Ge 17:7. +Ge 9:16. +Is 44:7 note. covenant. Is 54:10. 56:4. 59:21. Ge 15:18. Ex 6:4. Le 26:9. Dt 28:1. Jg 2:1. **2Sa 7:10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16. 1 Ch 16:17. +*Ps 74:20. **Ps 89:34. 111:9. Ro 11:27. He 8:8. 12:24. the sure mercies. +*Is 41:9. +*Is 54:8, 9, 10. +*Is 59:21. +**2Sa 7:10 note, 2Sa7:15. 23:5. 1 Ch 17:13. 2 Ch 1:8. 6:42. +*Ps 89:3, 28, 33, 35, 36, 37. +*Ps 132:11. +*Je 33:20, 21 note, Je 33:25, 26. **Ezk 37:24, 25. +**>Ac 13:34. of David. FS181E, +Ge 3:24. Is 38:5. 1 K 11:34. 2 K 20:5. +*Ps 89:49. Je 30:9. Ezk 34:23. 37:24. Ho 3:5. $+*Ac 13:23.
Jesus repeatedly challenged the religious authorities of his day as well as the common people by the question, “Have ye not read…” (Matthew 12:3). That question is recorded about ten times in the Gospels. Jesus expected people to know the Bible and to have read it. That, then, must be our authority.
Matthew 12:3 But he said unto them, Have ye not read what David did, when he was an hungred, and they that were with him;
Matthew 12:3. Have ye not read. ver. 5 (Mt 12:5). Mt 19:4. +Mt 21:16, 42. 22:31. Mk 2:25. 12:10, 26. Lk 6:3. 10:26. Jesus appealed repeatedly to the Bible alone as the source of spiritual authority. Notice the preceding cross references which document Christ’s repeated question, “Have ye not read?” Jesus expected his hearers to have read the Bible. He expects them to understand what they read (Mt 24:15 note). His question, “Have ye not read?” is recorded ten times! Jesus referred to seven distinct passages (Ge 1:27 at Mt 19:4; Ex 3:6 at Mt 22:31, 32; Le 24:6, 7, 8, 9 at Mt 12:3; Nu 28:9, 10 at Mt 12:5; 1 S 21:6 at Mt 12:3; Ps 8:2 at Mt 21:16; Ps 118:22 at Mt 21:42). Jesus appealed to the Bible as His authority many times, but never once did he appeal to the authority of the religious leaders in Israel (Pharisees or Sadducees), or to religious tradition. He commanded to “Search the Scriptures” (John 5:39). Two dozen times Jesus cites the Old Testament Prophets as recorded in the New Testament (Lk 24:27n). Even during His temptation in the wilderness, Jesus cited the Scripture, not tradition, when he resisted the Devil successfully. It seems we could learn something from that (Mt 4:4, 6, 7, 10). That the New Testament was written by the authority of Christ may be legitimately inferred from the fact that: (1) John explicitly records that Jesus Christ commanded him to WRITE (Revelation 1:19). (2) Jesus directly promised that the Holy Spirit would guide his apostles into all truth and bring all things to their remembrance (Jn 16:12, 13). Thus, as they wrote the writings we now have in the New Testament we are assured of their accuracy for they were written under divine inspiration (2Ti 3:16. 2Pe 1:21). Peter called the letters written by Paul “Scripture” (2Pe 3:16), and clearly possessed them as a well-known collection. Paul cites the words of Jesus, quoting them exactly, from Luke 10:7 in 1 Timothy 5:17, 18. The book of Revelation makes at least four direct quotations from the Gospels. By John’s death, the entire New Testament as we have it today was available and being read by or to all genuine Christians. Thus the claim by some Roman Catholics that Jesus gave us the Church, not the Bible, as our teaching authority and source of spiritual truth, the “pillar and ground of the truth” (1Ti 3:15 note), is untrue, for Jesus himself appealed to the authority of Scripture, not tradition or the religious institution of his day. Mt 9:13. +*Mt 22:29. Le 10:16, 17, 18, 19, 20. +Dt 17:19. Ps 119:139. Ac 13:27. what David did. *1Sa 21:3, 4, 5, 6. Mk 2:25, 26. Lk 6:3. and they. 1Sa 21:1, 2.
Jesus never appeals to so-called Tradition (like the Roman Catholics do) or to an official teaching authority like both the Roman Catholics and the Jehovah’s Witnesses do. On that basis I think these groups are false to the Scripture, and possibly false cults, and were predicted as long ago as the warning Paul gave to the Ephesian elders in Acts 20:27, 28, 29, 30. See also 1 Timothy 4:1 and 1 John 4:1.
Act 20:27 For I have not shunned to declare unto you all the counsel of God.
Act 20:28 Take heed therefore unto yourselves, and to all the flock, over the which the Holy Ghost hath made you overseers, to feed the church of God, which he hath purchased with his own blood.
Act 20:29 For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock.
Act 20:30 Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them.
I would particularly note that false claimants to spiritual authority started very early, being here spoken of in the book of Acts. Therefore, any claims based on the ability to trace an institution back to apostolic times are most suspect and actually invalid when their teachings do not match the apostolic record in the New Testament and the Bible as a whole. A good test of the truthfulness of any claim to supposed authority is to match the teaching of an institution, denomination, church, organization, theological system, or religious cult to the truth conveyed in Scripture as pointedly revealed by the cross references given for Isaiah 55:3 furnished above.
1 Timothy 4:1 Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils;
1Jn 4:1 Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.
The Watchtower denies the right of every individual to judge the correctness of a proposed (by them) interpretation of Scripture. Contrast 1 John 2:27 and 1 Corinthians 14:29. But Scripture plainly places the responsibility for judging the correctness of doctrinal teaching upon the believer according to Galatians 1:8.
1 John 2:27 But the anointing which ye have received of him abideth in you, and ye need not that any man teach you: but as the same anointing teacheth you of all things, and is truth, and is no lie, and even as it hath taught you, ye shall abide in him.
1 Corinthians 14:29 Let the prophets speak two or three, and let the other judge.
1 Corinthians 14:29. the prophets. ver. 32, 39 (1Co 14:32, 39). 1Co 12:10. +Ac 13:1. 15:32. Ro 12:6. *1 Th 5:19, 20, 21. 1 J 4:1, 2, 3. two or three. ver. 27n (1Co 14:27 note). the other. Rather, the others, io alloi. judge. or, discern, or discriminate. Gr. diakrinō (S#1252g, Ja 1:6). 1Co 2:15. 10:15. 12:10. *Jb 12:11. +*Is 8:20 note. +*Mk 4:24. +Lk 12:57. +*Ac 17:11. *1 Th 5:20, 21. *1 J 4:1.
I doubt very much that this commanded practice is followed in very many churches or congregations today! The others (note the plural, hidden by the King James Version) were directed to judge of the correctness of the teaching presented, apparently then and there, on the spot! But that demonstrates that the hearers were judged fully capable and were authorized, even directed, to make such judgments.
Gal 1:8 But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.
Galatians 1:8. though we. or, even if we. FS102C, +Mt 5:29. FS185B, +Ga 6:1. ver. 9 (Ga 1:9). Is 9:15. Je 16:20. *Je 23:16. 1Co 16:22. *2Co 11:13, 14. 1Ti 1:19, 20. Titus 3:10. **Re 22:18, 19. an angel. *1Ki 13:18 note. +*Ro 8:38. **2Co 11:14, 15. preach any other. T#1120. Individual Christian believers are here deemed competent to judge the doctrinal correctness of the preaching of an inspired apostle or even an angel from heaven, a very clear assertion of the Bible doctrine of the perspicuity of Scripture (Ps 119:104, 105. Pr 8:9. +Mt 12:3). This doctrine holds that, in all essential matters pertaining to faith and practice (Ps 19:7. 119:9, 11), the Bible is clearly understandable upon careful study to even the humblest believer (Ps 119:99, 100), without the interposition of an institutional or ecclesiastical authority to interpret the Scriptures for him (1 J 2:20, 27). Closely allied to this is the doctrine of the right and necessity of private judgment (Ac 17:11. 1Co 14:29. **1 Th 5:21 note), which holds that the individual is responsible directly to God for his beliefs (Ro 14:12), and that God will hold him responsible only to believe what is taught in Scripture (Is 8:20), apart from the teachings of humanly devised creeds and institutions, or unwritten traditions however hoary with age. The doctrines of perspicuity and private judgment having been clearly established as scriptural (see the following reference passages and their notes), the conclusion to be drawn is that the ultimate authority in spiritual or doctrinal matters is the written word of God found in the Bible, not the teachings of any man or group of men. Thus there can be no “one true church,” for any church is only “true” insofar as its teachings rest squarely upon and are in accordance with the teachings of the inerrant and infallible verbally inspired word of God in the Bible. +Ps 102:18 (T#49). **Ps 119:105, 130. +*Pr 8:9. +**Is 8:20 note. +*Je 23:28 note. +*Da 11:33 note. Mt 7:15. +*Mt 15:14. Mk 7:7, 8, 9. +Lk 12:57 (T#420). +**Jn 5:39 note. Jn 16:13 note. Ac 8:31 note. Ac 15:15. +**Ac 17:11. **Ro 14:12. +*Ro 15:4. 1Co 10:15. 14:29. 2Co 3:14. +*Ep 4:14. +*Col 1:23. 2:18. **1 Th 5:21. +**2Ti 3:15, 16, 17. **2Pe 1:19, 20 note. *1 J 2:20, 27. **1 J 4:1, 2. +*2 J 10. gospel. 1 Th 1:5. 1 P 5:12. than that. or, contrary to that. *Dt 4:2. *Dt 12:32. *Dt 13:8. Jsh 1:7. +*Pr 30:6. 2Co 11:4. **Re 22:18, 19. have preached. FS147A, +Ge 50:24. 1Ki 13:20 note, 21. let him. Ga 3:10, 13. 5:12 note. Ge 9:25. +*Le 15:8. +*Dt 27:15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26. Jsh 9:23. 1 S 26:19. *Ne 13:25. Pr 28:10. +**Je 10:25. +*Mt 15:14. 25:41. 2Pe 2:14. accursed. Gr. anathema (S#331g, Ac 23:14). Ga 3:10, 13. Jsh 7:1, 12. Mk 14:71. Ac 23:14. +Ro 9:3. +*1Co 12:3 note. *1Co 16:22g.
Check out references at Isaiah 8:20; 1 John 2:27; Matthew 12:3 and/or Matthew 24:15; John 5:39; 5:46; Acts 17:11; Luke 16:29-31; Mark 12:24. Note that last reference: Jesus did not charge them with error because they failed to accept the teaching from the authorized teaching authority (those that sit in “Moses’ seat” as Mt 23:2), or because they failed to know the official Traditions maintained by the one true Church. He roundly denounced them because they “knew not the Scriptures.” For the criticism by Jesus to be valid, it must have been possible then and now to know the Scriptures. The Scriptures, therefore, must be the sole authority, not a supposed “one true church” (like Roman Catholics would claim for their institution), or one true God-authorized organization (like the Jehovah’s Witnesses claim for their organization). God’s word issues stern warnings against giving heed to false teachers and false prophets. See the notes in the New Treasury at Jeremiah 14:14 and Ezekiel 14:10. See also Jeremiah 23:23, 28.
Jer 14:14 Then the LORD said unto me, The prophets prophesy lies in my name: I sent them not, neither have I commanded them, neither spake unto them: they prophesy unto you a false vision and divination, and a thing of nought, and the deceit of their heart.
Jeremiah 14:14. The prophets. Je 5:12. 5:31. 7:8. 8:11. 18:18. 20:6. +Je 23:25, 26, 30. 27:10, 14. 28:13. 29:21. 37:19. **Dt 18:20, 21, 22. 1Ki 22:6. +Pr 4:18 note. Is 9:15. La 4:13. Mic 2:11. 3:5. Zec 13:3. *Mt 7:15. 24:5. Mk 13:6. **1Ti 4:1, 2, 3. *Re 13:13, 14, 15. in my name. Dt 18:20. I sent. Je 23:14, 15, 16, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32. 27:14, 15. 28:15. 29:8, 9, 31. Ne 6:12. Is 30:10, 11. **2 Th 2:9, 10, 11. commanded. Je 7:22. neither spake. *Je 23:21. false vision. There are several marks of false cults.
False cults and mistaken religious faiths typically:
(1) Appeal to the wrong basis of authority, +*Is 8:20 note.
(2) Make exclusive claim to the truth, +*Pr 4:18 note.
(3) Claim superior experience or knowledge, Is 65:5 note.
(4) Distort the balance of Biblical truth, Is 43:10 note; Jn 16:13 note; **Ac 2:24 note.
(5) Deny the perspicuity of Scripture, +*Is 8:20 note; +*Pr 8:9.
(6) Deny the sufficiency of Scripture, +*2Ti 3:17.
(7) Deny the right of private or individual judgment and interpretation, Pr 18:1 note; Ro 14:12; %2Pe 1:20 note.
(8) Deny the full, eternal deity of Jesus Christ as the Second Person of the triune Godhead, or Trinity, Pr 8:22 note.
(9) Add to the written word of God additional revelation, whether in the form of authoritative writings or publications, or unwritten traditions, or new revelation, as from supernatural dreams, and supposed revelation through supernatural gifts of the Spirit, +*Je 23:28 note.
(10) Approach Scripture deductively with their closed system of belief, rather than inductively to learn its truth, 2Pe 1:20 note.
(11) Possess an innate, tenacious inability to receive new or corrective spiritual insight based upon additional light received from the continuing inductive study of Scripture, Ps 25:9; 119:18; +*Pr 4:18 note; 2Pe 1:20 note.
(12) Wrest Scripture, and handle it deceitfully, in a persistent effort to ignore, suppress, explain away, circumvent, or evade those texts which do not “fit” their deductively developed, arbitrarily imposed, system of belief upon Scripture, 2Co 4:2; 2Pe 3:16.
(13) Exert lordship over their follower’s faith, +*2Co 1:24, rather than encouraging submission to the Lordship of Christ, +**Ac 10:36.
(14) Fail to teach the obligation of each believer to carefully judge the truth of what is being taught, Ro 14:12; 1Co 14:29; Ga 1:8, 9; 1 Th 5:21.
(15) Fail to encourage the right of each believer to independently submit to the written word of God, Ps 119:18, 105; Ac 17:11, 12; 2Ti 2:15; +*2Ti 3:15, 16, 17; 1Pe 2:2.
(16) Impose a uniform system of belief upon all followers, rather than allow for individual differences in depth of knowledge to be reflected in honestly held differences of interpretation of Scripture and doctrinal understanding, Jn 16:12; Ac 18:24, 25, 26; Col 1:10; He 5:12; 2Pe 3:18.
(17) Deny legitimate Christian liberty by restricting the reading of followers to their own group’s publications, providing no open forum for the discussion of doctrinal differences, and not allowing participation in Bible studies not conducted by their own group, Jn 8:31, 32; 1Co 14:29; Ga 5:1; 3 J 9.
(18) Deny the Incarnation, that Jesus Christ is God come in flesh, the Second Person of the Trinity, 2 J 7 note.
(19) Have developed a very elaborate and quite convincing Biblical defense of their heresies, Pr 18:17.
(20) Mischaracterize the nature of God by ignoring the attributes they do not like and which do not harmonize with their system of doctrine, +**Ge 18:25 note.
(21) Accept and defend the materialist positions in theology in their denial of consciousness after death and eternal punishment, punishment that is eternal in duration not merely effect (Ge 2:17 note; Ge 3:4 note; +*Mt 10:28 note; +*Mt 25:46; Lk 23:43 note).
(22) Are characterized by proselytizing individuals already in the fellowship of genuinely Christian groups rather than winning unevangelized lost souls to faith in Christ, just like the Judaizers Paul roundly condemns (+*Ga 5:12; Jn 10:10; **Ac 20:30).
(23) Promote doctrinal distinctives which are generally not in accord with Bible teaching that properly follows the rules of interpretation (2Pe 1:20 note). Je 23:16. Is 28:7.
(24) Teach a mistaken doctrine of the Atonement of Christ (+**1 J 2:2 note).
(25) Fail to adhere to the Apostolic teaching regarding the eternal reign of Christ upon this earth (+**Lk 1:33; +**Is 9:7; +**2Ti 4:18 notes).
(26) Deny the continuing validity of the Abrahamic and Davidic Covenants with reference to the Land Promise made to Israel (Mal 3:6; **+Lev 26:42 note; +**Ac 7:5 note).
divination. Je 27:9, 10. 29:8, 9, 31. +Pr 16:10 mg. +Is 44:25. Ezk 12:24. 13:6, 7, 23. 21:29. Mic 3:11. Zec 10:2. and the deceit. Je 4:10. 23:26. Ge 3:5. Is 30:10. 56:10. La 2:14. their heart. Je 23:17. +Nu 16:28.