THE OBJECTION:
[Unfortunately, I am not able to figure out yet how to get back to the site where this discussion took place. The gist of the argument is that the Jews in Israel at the time did not accept Jesus as their Messiah (John 1:11). Therefore, Jesus must not have been the true expected Messiah for He did not fulfill the prophecies they expected the Messiah to fulfill.]
MY ANSWER:
Ibrahim Abdulrahman The problem with your argument is that you have failed to include all the evidence provided in the Bible on this theme.
Selecting part of the evidence and ignoring contrary evidence demonstrates your position is mistaken.
My constructive suggestion is that you start with a study of the fulfilled Bible prophecies about Jesus, the Messiah. Then proceed to a study of the unfulfilled Bible prophecies that pertain to the Second Coming of Christ.
If you have access to my published resource, The New Treasury of Scripture Knowledge, or its digital expansion, the Ultimate Cross Reference Treasury, this kind of study is easily done.
Lacking access to these resources, a good starting point would be to study the cross references I have provided for Micah 5:2 and Micah 5:3 which I share below from the UCRT:
Mic 5:2 But thou, Bethlehem Ephratah, though thou be little among the thousands of Judah, yet out of thee shall he come forth unto me that is to be ruler in Israel; whose goings forth have been from of old, from everlasting. (KJV)
Micah 5:2
But thou. >Mat 2:6, >Jhn 7:42.
Bethlehem. T1888, +Jos 19:15, Jdg 12:8; %Jdg 17:7, $Mat 2:1; $Mat 2:6, $Luk 2:4, 5, 6, Jhn 7:42, Heb 7:14.
Ephratah. Gen 35:16; Gen 35:19; +Gen 48:7, Ephrath. Jos 12:9 note. +Ruth 1:2; Ruth 4:11, 1Sa 17:12, +1Ch 2:50; +1Ch 2:51; +1Ch 2:54; 1Ch 4:4, Psa 132:6.
little. Jdg 6:15, 1Co 1:27, 28, 29.
among. 1Sa 10:19; 1Sa 23:23.
thousands. +Exo 18:21; +Exo 18:25 <rp. Num 1:16, Deut 1:15, +Jos 22:21, Jdg 6:15; Jdg 12:6 mg,note. Jdg 15:15 note. 1Sa 6:19 note. 1Sa 8:12; 1Sa 10:19; 1Sa 17:18; 1Sa 23:23, 1Ki 20:30 note. 1Ch 12:20; 1Ch 15:25; 1Ch 27:1.
of Judah. Deut 33:7, +1Ch 5:2, %+Psa 60:7, $Mat 2:6, $Heb 7:14, $Rev 5:5.
yet. Isa 11:1; Isa 53:2, Ezk 17:22, 23, 24, *Amos 9:11, Luk 2:4, 5, 6, 7, 1Co 1:27, 28.
out of thee. Num 24:19, Isa 11:1, Jhn 7:27.
shall he. Psa 23:1; Psa 78:71, Jer 23:4, Zec 13:7, Act 13:32; Act 26:6, Heb 5:5.
come forth. Jer 33:14, Ezk 21:27, Dan 9:25, %*Zec 9:9; Zec 12:8, Mat 11:3; Mat 21:5, Luk 2:6; Luk 7:19; +**Luk 24:27, Jhn 1:45, Gal 4:4, =1Th 4:16.
that is. +*Gen 49:10, 1Ch 5:2, +*Isa 9:6; +*Isa 9:7, +*Jer 23:5; +*Jer 23:6, Ezk 34:23, 24; Ezk 37:22, 23, 24, 25, *Zec 9:9, Mat 28:18, +**Luk 1:31, 32, 33; Luk 23:2; Luk 23:38, Jhn 19:14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 1Ti 3:16, Rev 19:16.
ruler. 1Ch 11:2, Psa 28:9, Isa 55:4, Jer 30:9; Jer 30:21, Ezk 37:24, **Jhn 1:49, +*Act 2:30; =Act 7:35; +*Act 10:36, *Rom 9:5, Col 1:20, 1Ti 1:17.
in Israel. +*Act 1:6.
whose goings forth. +Gen 22:15 note. *Psa 90:2; Psa 102:25, 26, 27, *Pro 8:22; *Pro 8:23, +*Jhn 1:1, 2, 3; **Jhn 8:58, *Col 1:17, +*Heb 13:8, *1Jn 1:1; *1Jn 1:2, *Rev 1:11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18; Rev 2:8; Rev 21:6.
from. *Psa 55:19; Psa 93:2, Isa 43:13, Dan 7:9, Jhn 1:15; +*Jhn 8:58.
of old. Heb. kedem, +S# H6924. Always used of the past; rendered (1) ever, Pro 8:23, (2) eternal, Deut 33:27, (3) everlasting, **Hab 1:12, (4) old, Neh 12:46, Psa 44:1; Psa 55:19; Psa 68:33; Psa 74:2; Psa 77:5; Psa 77:11; Psa 78:2; Psa 119:152; Psa 143:5, Jer 46:26, Lam 1:7; Lam 2:17, Mic 7:20, (5) ancient, Deut 33:15, 2Ki 19:25, Isa 19:11; Isa 23:7; Isa 37:26; Isa 45:21; Isa 46:10; Isa 51:9, (6) past, Job 29:2, (7) aforetime, Jer 30:20, (8) before, Psa 139:5, Pro 8:22.
from. T76-3, Psa 72:17, Pro 8:22, 23, 24, +*Jhn 1:1; +*Jhn 1:2; +*Jhn 8:35; +*Jhn 8:58; *Jhn 17:5, *1Jn 1:1; *1Jn 1:2, +*Rev 1:8; +*Rev 1:17.
everlasting. or, the days of eternity. Heb. olam, +Gen 17:7, FS22D4B, +Dan 7:9. Mic 7:14, Deut 33:27, **Psa 90:2; Psa 93:2, *Pro 8:22; *Pro 8:23, Isa 57:15, Hab 1:12, *Jhn 1:1; *Jhn 1:2; **Jhn 6:54 note. Rom 16:26, Php 2:6, 1Pe 1:20, Rev 1:4.
Mic 5:3 Therefore will he give them up, until the time that she which travaileth hath brought forth: then the remnant of his brethren shall return unto the children of Israel. (KJV)
Micah 5:3
Therefore. Mic 7:13, Hos 2:9; Hos 2:14.
give them up. Mic 6:14, 1Ki 14:16, 2Ch 30:7, Isa 49:1-23, Hos 11:8, Zec 13:7, 8, 9, **+Mat 21:43.
until the time. +*Psa 102:13; +*Psa 102:16, Hos 3:4, 5; +*Hos 5:15; Hos 6:2, *Mat 19:28; +*Mat 23:39, +*Luk 21:24, +**Act 3:19, +*Rom 11:25.
she which travaileth. *Mic 4:10, +*Gen 3:15, +*Isa 7:14; +*Isa 66:7; +*Isa 66:8, $Mat 1:21; $Mat 1:23; +*Mat 24:8, *Jhn 16:21; *Jhn 16:22, Gal 4:4, *Rev 12:1; *Rev 12:2.
brought forth. **Mat 19:28, Rev 12:5.
then the remnant. Mic 5:7, 8, Mic 2:12; +Mic 4:7; Mic 7:18, +Isa 1:9; *Isa 10:5; *Isa 10:6; *Isa 10:20, 21, 22; Isa 11:11; Isa 37:4; Isa 37:31, Jer 23:3; Jer 31:1; Jer 31:7, 8, 9, Ezk 6:8; +Ezk 14:22, Joel 2:32, Amos 5:15, Zep 2:7; Zep 2:9; Zep 3:13, Rom 9:27, 28; Rom 11:4, 5, 6.
his brethren. Mat 12:50; Mat 25:40, Rom 8:29, *Heb 2:11; *Heb 2:12.
I will immediately attempt to post this material on my Real Bible Study website where the cross references will be “live” and readable upon mouse-over.